C&G Law Office
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Expertise & Experience
  • News
  • Cofounders
  • Legal Team
  • Contact

Tag: Turkish Legal System

Home Posts Tagged "Turkish Legal System"

WITHHOLDING TAX FOR FOREIGN E-COMMERCE

21 July 2017Burcu Canpolat

EcommerceTechnology is disruptive especially when it comes to State power. It overrides territorial borders and their rules on taxation. E-commerce is one of the elements that technology allowed. States are now trying to impose their borders against borderless worldwide internet. In Turkey, finance minister, Naci Agbal, promised the establishment of a withholding tax in order to impose tax on foreign-based e-commerce companies. The question arising out of this declaration is the way it will be done compared to the solutions found in France and China.

In the end of Spring 2017, Naci Agbal gave an interview to Habertürk[1] where he explicitly stated that its ministry is planning a withholding tax over foreign e-commerce transactions. Newspapers in Turkey have relayed this news as the coming of an equitable time[2]. The Finance Minister declared that this withholding tax will be taken by banks when the money is transferred from the customer to the e-commerce company. Indeed, he only refers to companies which are not registered in Turkey and that do not pay any taxes in Turkey. This is purported to bring an equal treatment between national e-commerce companies and foreign e-commerce companies. The former are paying all their taxes in Turkey while the latter were not paying anything in Turkey while capturing a portion of Turkish consumers. This is an unbalanced situation that the minister wants to end. To implement this tax, the finance minister promised to hire 100-200 more staff in the revenue administration in order to follow the implementation. He affirmed that this tax would be taken both for services and goods.

President of the Turkish Payment and Electronic Money Institution (ÖDED), Burhan Eliaçik, stated that online shopping on foreign e-commerce companies represented ₺5,4 billions (around €331 millions) in 2016. He foresees around ₺8 billions (around €972 millions) in 2020 and imagines the millions of tax that could be taken from this shopping.[3]

However, the declaration of the minister has been analyzed by some experts in different newspapers and problems of implementation seem to appear.

Indeed, the first problem seems to be the effect of these measures on Turkish e-commerce companies abroad. It is said that the bilateral tax agreements preventing double taxation will be applied and Turkish e-commerce companies selling abroad could be subjected to the same kind of tax in the country of performance.[4] This could hinder their benefits abroad.

The second problem is the case when the company is foreign however the seller is Turkish[5]. Indeed, there are different business models and some of them are just about linking the seller and the buyer. Hence; the following questions, “How could this automatic withholding tax know about these details?” “Will the bank have enough information to carry out this role of taking taxes from these transfers?” are legit questions because of the lack of information on this future withholding tax.

However, Turkish companies operating e-commerce websites are quite pleased with this news. The president of a well-known Turkish e-commerce website stated that the lack of taxation of foreign e-commerce companies led to an unfair competition. He even argues that this decision could act as an incentive to invest in Turkey.

The examples of France and China may be taken to have an idea of the current practices of other countries. In 8 April 2016, China established a tax on parcels with a limit of 2.000._CNY and pursuant to this regulation, only tax and VAT must be paid on 70% of the value of the declared goods on the parcel. However, above that level, customs duty must be added to it[6].

However, in France, it works differently: intra-European e-commerce is dealt differently than international e-commerce. Hence, for Europe, VAT registration is required when the turnover of the company in France exceeds €35.000. Otherwise, the company can impose the VAT of the country of exportation. However, outside the European Union, customs duty must be paid for each parcel and any VAT shall not be imposed until 22 euros. This loophole of products under €22 will not be available from 2018 as it does not bring a fair competition between national and foreign e-commerce companies[7]. However, the French system does not seem to work properly as some recent news emphasized on the massive loss due to the lack of implementation.[8]

As seen above, the regulation documents are still on progress. It would be interesting to see how Turkey will deal with this question considering the failure of France because of the European Union and due to the possibility of an easy fiscal dumping.

[1] BUSINESS HT (2017), E-Ticaret’e stopaj geliyor. http://www.businessht.com.tr/ekonomi/haber/1527447-e-ticaret-e-stopaj-geliyor

[2] HURRIYET (2017), E-ticarette adil dönem http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/e-ticarette-adil-donem-40488067

[3] AKSAM (2017), Yabancı e-ticaret sitelerine vergi yüz milyonlarca TL gelir yaratır http://www.aksam.com.tr/ekonomi/yabanci-e-ticaret-sitelerine-vergi-yuz-milyonlarca-tl-gelir-yaratir/haber-637264

[4] HUKUKI HABER (2017), E-ticarette adil dönem http://www.hukukihaber.net/ekonomi/e-ticarette-adil-donem-h93767.html

[5] DIGITAL AGE (2017), Haziran ayında bilişim hukuku gelişmeleri. http://digitalage.com.tr/haziran-ayinda-bilisim-hukuku-gelismeleri/

[6] MERIDIAN GLOBAL SERVICES (2016), Chine: taxe sur l’e-commerce étranger. https://www.meridianglobalservices.fr/Chine-taxe-sur-le-commerce-étranger/

[7] EUROPEAN COMMISSION – Press release : La Commission propose de nouvelles règles fiscales afin d’encourager le commerce électronique et de soutenir les entreprises en ligne au sein de l’UE. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-16-4010_fr.htm

[8] LE FIGARO (2010), L’e-commerce contourne la fiscalité française.  http://www.lefigaro.fr/societes/2010/04/07/04015-20100407ARTFIG00419-l-e-commerce-contourne-la-fiscalite-francaise-.php

CONTRACT DRAFTING & REVIEW

11 November 2016Nihan Geliş

As our legal team do not think or work only as lawyers but also as business men, merchants, investors, financiers, engineers and any kind of technical person as the case may necessitate; we better define the strategy and the needs of our clients when drafting and reviewing the international contracts where the parties are subject to different laws.

Besides basic types of contract such as construction, sale & purchase, transportation, service, rent and employment contracts; we also advise on review and drafting consortium agreements, Terms and Conditions, Letter of Intent, NDA  and any specific type of agreements that our clients may require during their business. And by virtue of our knowledge of multi languages, we provide the legal translations of the said contracts, when needed.

DISPUTE RESOLUTION

11 November 2016Nihan Geliş

When a dispute arises, our first goal is to help our client to resolve the dispute via alternative dispute resolutions methods.

However if the litigation is inevitable; we try to better understand the merit of the case by means of our close cooperation with technical experts related to the subject of the dispute and we represent our client in all court instances by providing the appropriate injunctions and other preliminary reliefs and collection of evidences.

And apart from litigation; as the members of Chartered Institute of Arbitration (CIArb), we also arbitrate cases to conclusion to serve the needs of our clients.

PATENTS&TRADEMARKS

11 November 2016Nihan Geliş

Our team has also the breadth and depth of experience in the intellectual property law. Accordingly, we advises our clients on the full array of their IP legal and business needs such as prosecution, litigation, transactional services, and commercialization of IP assets as well as the patents, trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets or other IP-related matters.

FIDIC CONTRACTS

11 November 2016Nihan Geliş

As certified advisors of International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC); C&G advises on preparation and management of FIDIC Contracts such as Measurement/Lump sum/Turnkey Contracts, Design&Build / Design&Build&Operate Contracts, Subcontractor Agreements, as well as their prosecutions of claims. Our law office regularly involves in big and medium sized construction projects of any kind of major infrastructure investments in Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Asia and Africa such as power, gas pipelin and water treatment plant projects, railway, road, dam projects..etc. and Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) Contracts.

Benzer Yazılar

  • CONTRACT DRAFTING & REVIEW
  • RENEWABLE ENERGY RESOURCES IN TURKEY
  • PATENTS&TRADEMARKS
  • WITHHOLDING TAX FOR FOREIGN E-COMMERCE


Kategoriler

  • Articles
  • Expertise & Experience
  • News

Etiketler

AB agreement arbitration arbitration agreement cheque CISG consortium construction contract construction of energy production facilities contract dispute resolution dud cheque employer employment contract Eurpean Union findeks fit for purpose fitness for purpose foreign investment free trade free zone free zones in Turkey interbational arbitration International Carriage of Goods by Road international lawyer international road union international trade istanbul law lawyer Power Plant Engineering and Construction QR Code risk sale of goods tax exemption trade transportation Turkey Turkish Turkish companies Turkish Law Turkish Legal System VAT vienna convention warranty
Tüm Hakları Saklıdır C&G Law Office
Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Türkiye Barolar Birliği’nin meslek kuralları doğrultusunda hazırlanmış işbu websitesi içeriği, Avukatlık Meslek Ahlakı kurallarına uygun olarak düzenlenmiş ve Reklam Yasağı Yönetmeliği ile Avrupa’da Avukatların Tabi Olduğu Meslek Kuralları uyarınca güncellenmiştir. C&G Avukatlık Bürosu işbu websitesini müvekkillerinin ve diğer kullanıcıların sadece bilgi edinmesi amacıyla yayımlamış olup, işbu websitesindeki tüm içerik halihazırdaki en güncel hukuki gelişmeleri, karar veya uzlaşmaları yansıtmayabilir. İşbu websitesindeki bilgiler; reklam amaçlı olmayıp, yasal tavsiye niteliğinde değildir ve C&G Avukatlık Bürosu’nun ya da herhangi bir müvekkilinin veya çalışanının görüşlerini yansıtmaz ve bu bilgilerin doğru, eksiksiz veya güncel olduğu garanti edilmez. C&G Avukatlık Bürosu işbu websitesindeki içeriğin tamamı ya da bir bölümüyle ilgili olarak doğrudan veya kısmen herhangi birine karşı yapılan ya da yapılması ihmal edilen herhangi bir işlemden veya herhangi bir işlemin sonuçlarından dolayı ortaya çıkabilecek tüm sorumluluğu açıkça reddeder. İşbu websitesindeki bilgi aktarımı, gönderen ve alıcı arasında herhangi bir avukat- müvekkil ilişkisi oluşturma amaçlı değildir. C&G Avukatlık Bürosu, websitesi aracılığıyla ulaşılabilecek herhangi bir üçüncü kişi içeriği bakımından sorumluluk kabul etmez. Çok gizli bilgi olduğu için, C&G Avukatlık Bürosu, sadece referans amaçlı bile olsa, müvekkillerinin isimlerini açıklamaz. C&G Avukatlık Bürosu logosu, işbu websitesindeki bilgi ve bu bilgilere bağlı fikri ve sınai haklar, C&G Avukatlık Bürosu’na aittir ve ait kalacaktır; ve bunlar C&G Avukatlık Bürosu’nun yazılı onayı olmaksızın kullanılamaz, kopyalanamaz ve/veya çoğaltılamaz.

Bize yazın